roomly
Search stays
All stays in New York
This data is over 30 days old
Pull every review and social post now. This takes up to a minute.

Ameritania at Times Square

230 W 54th Street · New York, US
FitnessFamily friendlyPet friendly
85
Excellent
9,526 reviews · 22 posts · 4.3 / 5
/ night
Checking live rates…
Checking what this stay usually costs…
Book now
Book a refundable rate and we'll re-price this room every few hours until you check in. Every time it drops we email you — one tap and the lower rate is yours.
Recommended
Guests agree across the web, and just 28% of the themes they keep raising are complaints.
Luxurious Accommodations - Experience the epitome of comfort and style in our guest rooms at Ameritania. Boasting designer bath amenities, cable TVs, and elegant decor, each room offers a lavish retreat in the heart of New York City.
What builds this score
Verified stays
82
Local reviews
Public reviews
Travel reviews
88
How we calculate it
Social reach · not part of the score
5 on Instagram · 12 on TikTok
Read it yourself

What's at this hotel

Fitness facilitiesWiFi availableFree WiFiParkingNon-smoking roomsAir conditioningFitness center24-hour front deskHeatingFamily roomsPets allowedLift / Elevator

As published by the property. Room-level facilities are listed against each room when you pick your dates.

The short version
Guests love
  • Prime location near Times Square and subways319 mentions
  • Helpful and accommodating staff303 mentions
  • Complimentary morning coffee and bottled water82 mentions
Guests flag
  • Dark decor and outdated room condition74 mentions
  • Exterior construction and scaffolding66 mentions
  • Loud air conditioning and street noise62 mentions
Ranked by how often each point comes up across the reviews we read. We never edit or remove ratings.

What guests keep saying

Read across a sample of 640 of this stay's 9,526 reviews, plus 22 posts. Percentages are of the sample.
Prime location near Times Square and subways
+
Guests consistently praise the hotel's central location close to Times Square, Central Park, Broadway shows, and subway lines.
319 mentions · 50% of 640 reviews
Helpful and accommodating staff
+
Several reviewers highlight specific friendly staff members who assisted with early check-ins, luggage storage, and general support.
303 mentions · 47% of 640 reviews
Complimentary morning coffee and bottled water
+
Visitors appreciate free daily bottled water and morning coffee served in the hotel lobby.
82 mentions · 13% of 640 reviews
Dark decor and outdated room condition
Reviewers frequently mention dim lighting, dark room decor, and aged carpets or furnishings that need updating.
74 mentions · 12% of 640 reviews
Exterior construction and scaffolding
Guests note active building work and window scaffolding that forces them to keep window shades drawn all day.
66 mentions · 10% of 640 reviews
Loud air conditioning and street noise
Guests complain about excessively loud air conditioners and single-pane windows that let in street noise.
62 mentions · 10% of 640 reviews
Frequent elevator breakdowns
Numerous reviewers report frequent elevator outages, leaving guests stuck or forcing them to climb many flights of stairs.
40 mentions · 6% of 640 reviews
Inconsistent hot water and shower issues
Multiple guests report plumbing problems such as cold water shortages or awkward half-glass shower doors that flood the bathroom floor.
37 mentions · 6% of 640 reviews

Reviews, in their own words

Pulled from every source we read, deduplicated and badged.
A
Ana Paglione
Verified guest reviews · Aug 21, 2026
5.0
Boa localização. Está em reforma do lado de fora. Carpete sujo, roupas de cama envelhecidas, péssimo atendimento.
X
Xavier C
Traveller reviews · Aug 1, 2026
5.0
Flawless. Will definitely be back.
A
Aylin
Verified guest reviews · Aug 21, 2026
9.0
Konun ve olanaklar harikaydı
L
Lee S
Traveller reviews · Aug 1, 2026
5.0
This is the best hotel in Midtown for the Price. No question. Excellent accommodations, friendly staff—all at the most reasonable price that anyone could imagine in New York. Close to Subway connections. Nightlife is vibrant without being noisy. Rooms were nicely furnished, and had completeamenities. I will stay here every time. I’m in New York.
Y
Yan F
Verified guest reviews · Aug 20, 2026
8.0
Overall it is very nice. Since it is in a busy location. It can be a little noisy.
Overall it is very nice. Since it is in a busy location. It can be a little noisy. Very conveniently located. There is no body wash gel in the shower room but with two shampoo.

What it looks like on social

22 social posts from around the web, weighted alongside the reviews.
Checking rates…
Includes taxes and fees
Price Watch included
Book now